Andy Cohen isn't pleading the fifth when it comes to Summer House's latest love triangle.

Following the bombshell revelation that Amanda Batula and West Wilson are dating, many of their fellow Bravo stars, have shared their thoughts—not to mention set the record straight on when they learned about the romance. And that includes the Watch What Happens Live! host who revealed he was just as surprised as fans were to learn about the new couple.

"I saw a lot of conspiracy theories online yesterday that I somehow knew about this," Andy told fans during his SiriusXM Andy Cohen Live radio show April 1 before clarifying, "I did not."

After all, the romance reveal made waves as Amanda and estranged husband Kyle Cooke had confirmed their separation just two months prior. Plus, the drama between West’s 2023 breakup with Amanda’s BFF Ciara Miller had only just begun to settle on the most recent season of Summer House.

Noting "I really feel for Ciara" amid the cast's friendship fallout, Andy added he was somewhat puzzled by Amanda and West's March 31 joint statement confirming their romance.

"I was surprised by the statement," the 57-year-old noted. "I was surprised by what it said and I was surprised by what it didn't say."

Good thing Andy is scheduled to host the Bravo reality series' season 10 reunion later this month.

"I have so many questions," the father to Ben, 7, and Lucy, 3, admitted, "and the reunion is coming up and, boy, do I have a lot of questions."

And while Amanda and West have received some backlash after going public with their relationship—especially since Ciara fully supported her BFF through Amanda's split from Kyle—Andy shared a warning with Bravo viewers.

As he shared, "I do think it's worth reminding everybody, all the passionate fans of the show, that these are real people involved."

Andy emphasized "there's a middle ground" between overreacting and taking the news in stride. "But just know," he advised, "these are real people who are dealing with a lot."

In their joint statement, Amanda and West explained why they waited nearly a month to address the speculation about their "very new" romance.

"Given the complicated relationship dynamics involved and the scrutiny that comes with being on a reality show, we needed a little space to process things privately before speaking on it," the couple wrote. "Through all the highs and lows, and what’s developed recently was the last thing either of us expected. Our connection grew out of a genuine, long-standing friendship, which made it especially important for us to approach this with care."

They added, "We also recognize that this has never had an impact beyond just us and never wanted our actions to cause any hurt or be perceived as careless," the pair added. "We truly appreciate the understanding and respect as we navigate this."

Though Ciara has not directly commented on the drama, Kyle subsequently broke his silence on his ex moving on with his good friend.

“I'm good, I’m actually really worried about Amanda, if I’m being honest,” the Loverboy funder told NYC-based journalist Adam Glyn in a TikTok video posted April 1. “I talked to her before their statement came out, she gave me a heads up, and I talked to her last night. I understand people have all sorts of opinions and I'm not justifying any kind of behavior, but from what I'm seeing she's kind of getting cyber bullied.”

“Amanda knows that what she did was wrong,” Kyle added, “and she's trying to come to terms with it. But she is not well.”

Keep reading for a closer look at the timeline of events behind West, Amanda and Ciara's Summer House love triangle.

July-December 2023: Ciara Miller, West Wilson Date Briefly & Break Up

After finding love while filming Summer House's season eight, Ciara Miller and series newbie West Wilson took their romance from TV to real life in 2023.

However, their romance wouldn't last long, with the costars breaking up at the end of that year.

The messy split caused friction in the summer house over the next two seasons, with Ciara struggling over whether or not to forgive the sports reporter for breaking her heart and ultimately give their relationship another try.

January 2026: Amanda Batula & Kyle Cooke Announce Separation

Following years of contentious ups and downs in their relationship, Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke decided to officially end their four-year marriage ahead of the Bravo series' 10th season began airing in 2026.

“After much reflection, we have mutually and amicably decided to part ways as a couple,” the longtime costars shared in a joint statement posted to their Instagram Stories Jan. 19. “We share this with a heavy heart and kindly ask for your grace and support while we focus on our personal growth and healing.”

Amanda and Kyle, who tied the knot in September 2021, continued, “It feels ironic to ask for privacy during this time since we've always tried to be open and honest about our relationship, but your kindness and respect will go a long way as we try to navigate our next chapter.”

Viewers got a front row seat on their road to breakup as their relationship problems played out on the show.

March 5, 2026: Amanda Batula, West Wilson Spark Dating Rumors

Rumors surrounding Amanda and West's alleged romance began spreading like wildfire after gossip blog Deuxmoi first reported on March 5 that the costars were spotted together getting flirty in NYC.

Responding to the speculation, West downplayed the buzz during a Watch What Happens Live appearance on March 24 saying, "She's single now and it happened already to other people she's hung out with. We were just hanging out in New York. She's single now, I gotta show her the streets a little."

"That's a friend," the sports journalist added. "But if it's not clear, that's a very important person to me. Like, I care about her a lot."

In response to the alleged hookup, several of West and Amanda's costars shared their thoughts on the rumored romance.

Carl Radke shared a photo of himself looking confused to his Instagram Stories March 29, with Lindsay Hubbard and KJ Dillard posting similar "WTF?" expressions on their socials.

Fellow Bravo star Austen Kroll—who is friends with many Summer House castmates—seemingly entered the chat with the Southern Charm star writing on his Instagram Stories March 29, "Pasta and f--k your friends exes are apparently so back."

March 31, 2026: Amanda Batula & West Wilson Confirm Romance

Amanda and West broke their silence on the matter in a bombshell joint Instagram statement on March 31, confirming the rumors were true.

"It was never our intention to purposely hide anything," the message, addressing their "very new" romance, shared to their Instagram Stories read. "Given the complicated relationship dynamics involved and the scrutiny that comes with being on a reality show, we needed a little space to process things privately before speaking on it."

"We also recognize that this has never had an impact beyond just us and never wanted our actions to cause any hurt or be perceived as careless," the pair added. "We truly appreciate the understanding and respect as we navigate this."

March 2026: Ciara Miller Comforted Amid Love Triangle Drama

The same day that West and Amanda announced their romance, Ciara was photographed in NYC being comforted by a male friend. The former nurse also began receiving support from friends and costars on social media as her fellow Bravolebrities began taking sides amid the scandalous love triangle.

Amanda's estranged husband Kyle Cooke seemingly poked fun at the drama with the 43-year-old posting a selfie with Ciara on Instagram March 30.

Meanwhile, Summer House alum Paige DeSorbo gave a sweet shout out to Ciara in an Instagram comment writing, "Ur perfect," while Lindsay Hubbard and season 10 newcomer Dara Levitan also proved they are Team Ciara, with Lindsay commenting, “Perfection,” and Dara adding, “And that’s how you do it.”