Jay-Z‘s legacy has been a topic of debate on social media the last several years.
The Brooklyn MC’s standing as Rap GOAT Emeritus to the fans that worship his bars and his business influence have ruffled some feathers to the point where uninformed theories have been a growing theme when social media accounts talk about him. One of the more fascinating (and dumb) arguments that’s been made is that he was never the “biggest” rapper during any given year while he was in his prime, as if records sold and charting singles are the sole measurements of a rapper’s legacy. Well, I’m here to tell you that it’s not and will never be. Not to any real self-respecting rap fan anyway.
What people have to understand about Jay is that regardless of the albums sold or Billboard Hot 100 hits he’s accumulated over the course of his storied career, rappers of his era still either respected or envied his business acumen even if they weren’t the biggest fans of his music. He owned the label he was releasing music under. It’s like if Michael Jordan owned the Bulls. That’s why a certain class of street hustler his drug tales resonated with a certain type of street hustler from the first time they saw the skinny dude on the boat in the “In My Lifetime” music video. I had never heard of the Robb Report before Jay name-dropped the luxury lifestyle magazine on “Only a Customer” when he rapped, “As you thumb through The Source, I read the Robb Report.” His music has always been aspirational and trendsetting while also delving into the guilt-ridden psyche of a good kid navigating a mad city. Do you fools listen to music or do you just skim through it?
Jigga and his Roc-A-Fella clique popularized phrases like “holla” and “pause.” He was one of the first rappers with a successful clothing line in Rocawear that people actually wanted to wear. Kids in the New York City area were seeking out all-white Nike Air Force 1s (and keeping them clean) during the mid-’90s way before Nelly dropped that song in 2002. He had people dismissing the Range Rover 4.0 SE in favor of the more expensive 4.6 HSE and had everyone from fans at the club to rappers in their MTV Cribs showing off their collection of gold Cristal champagne bottles. When he told fans to stash their throwback jerseys away in favor of button-ups, they listened. He inspired your favorite rappers to make claims that they don’t write. He might not have been the most popular rapper, but he damn sure was the most important one of his era, especially when it involved business, slang, style and music.
DMX, who had a year that most artists dream about when he dropped two platinum albums in 1998, made it his business to give his frenemy a shout on his third project … And Then There Was X when he proclaimed, “Look at all these off-brand n—as/ Runnin’ around yappin’ ’bout they be holdin’ figgas as big as Jigga’s,” on “What’s My Name,” the album’s lead single that dropped the same day as Hova’s fourth album Vol. 3… Life and Times of S. Carter in which he stands in the middle of the Twin Towers on the album cover. That’s one of the biggest rappers of that era taking time to acknowledge his peer’s hustle. By 1999, Jay was already building himself an empire and legacy that made him and his rep unassailable to the point where even his biggest competitors knew they couldn’t realistically touch him.
For the people that were at Jay-Z’s three-night residency at Yankee Stadium – or even the kids who followed at home over social media — this shouldn’t need to be explained. I get that New York City is his homebase, but I was still in awe of what I witnessed in the Bronx over the weekend. This wasn’t a concert series, it was more like a pilgrimage: That’s what I said to myself after I saw what was in front of me when I walked up the stairs of the subway station in front of the McDonald’s across the street from Yankee Stadium during that first night. There was a sea of people and clouds of weed smoke as far as the eyes could see. You heard bootleggers announcing that they had shirts, hats, water, nutcrackers and Henny Coladas for sale over the random people playing Jay-Z records from portable speakers, big and small. The energy in the air was infectious.
The decision to have these anniversary shows at Yankee Stadium wasn’t lost on me. Jay himself is a generation-spanning New York institution, just as the Bronx Bombers are. The Yankee fitteds, the merch, the white Uptowns, the large crowds, the buzz and the intensity gave the weekend a playoff atmosphere. I’ve been to plenty of big games there, including the title-clinching Game 6 of the 2009 World Series, and I’ve never seen that many humans outside of that stadium. This is only a moment an artist of Jigga’s stature could pull off.
There’s also a thread tying the start of his own dynasty in 1996 with the release of Reasonable Doubt to the Yankees beginning a new dynasty that very same year. That ‘96 Yankee team were considered underdogs just as he was early in his career. They were the first Wild Card team to get to the World Series and they beat a heavily favored Atlanta Braves team that boasted one of the greatest starting pitching rotations in the history of the sport. And when he dropped The Blueprint in 2001, he was sitting at the top of the game just as the Yankees were. New York had won three straight titles and were on their way to play in their fourth straight Fall Classic that October.
Seeing Hov perform both his debut album and his most important in their entirety on back-to-back nights in the middle of Major League Baseball’s cathedral was nothing short of a spiritual experience. It felt like a big party with thousands of people going bar-for-bar as he stood on stage and rifled through songs from Reasonable Doubt, The Blueprint and a handful of loosies, B-sides, and hit records. I unfortunately wasn’t in attendance during the third night and will have fomo for a long time, even with all the bulls—t, because you can never put a price on having a story to tell.
I know he’s said, “Men lie, women lie, numbers don’t” and “Only dudes moving units: Em, Pimp Juice and us,” in the past, but as impressive as 14 No. 1 albums on the Billboard 200 and over 100 Billboard Hot 100 hits including four No. 1s are, they’ll never tell the whole story when it comes to Jay-Z. Before Vol. 2… Hard Knock Life, when he sold “five mil,” his influence was subtle, quietly reserved for the “If you know, you know” crowd. If you weren’t there then you wouldn’t get it and that’s okay. It happened before the social media era. Talk to your uncles, aunts, older siblings and cousins. Talk to the people that were there in real time experiencing it. Ask them why their white on white Air Forces are always clean and see if they tie it back the Roc-A-Fella era.
After this weekend, the questionable legacy talk should be finally put to bed. Now, go do a deep dive into the catalog and shut up. Jigga held you down eight summers, damn, where’s the love?